04.02.11

Bill Gates and Nathan Myhrvold Find New Ways to Extort the Competitors, Using Patents

Posted in Bill Gates, GNU/Linux, Google, Microsoft, Patents at 5:56 pm by Dr. Roy Schestowitz

Nathan Myhrvold

Summary: The world’s biggest patent trolls proceed to extorting Blackberry users/devices; more news about software patents, mostly those which affect Android and Linux

APPALLING. That’s what Microsoft appears to have given the world. First it put a tax on every computer sold, removing people’s ability to avoid this tax even if they want nothing to do with Microsoft. Now they want to force people to pay Microsoft a tax no matter which phone they buy. That’s right, and if it’s not Microsoft pulling those strings, then it’s the two co-founders of the company and their former CTO, who with funding from a Microsoft co-founder created the world’s largest patent troll, Intellectual Ventures. Watch how patent lawyer types try to white-wash the patent trolls’ role in industry and cover the fact that Gates and his buddy Myhrvold are extorting RIM for its phones, just like HTC and Samsung (for Linux), allegedly after Myhrvold did his blackmail routines. Here is how patent lawyers put it (subscription required):

RIM signs up with IV as RPX hits 80 http://is.gd/c7j7YP

The sources the Microsoft-apathetic folks cite describe this extortion as some sort of “protection” or “access to patents”. This is nonsense. It’s spin. To be fair, Myhrvold is not the only patent troll who is extorting companies for their phones and also passes patents for other trolls to sue companies which do not pay to enter his pyramid scheme. For example we have this in the news:

Turns out, that patent exists — and the company that owns it is looking to sue juuuust about everyone.

The patent in question was granted back in 2009, to a company called HW Technology. Now they’re taking on Apple and their App Store, Google and their Android Market, and RIM and their BlackBerry App World. Oh, and HTC, LG, and Nokia. Oh! And Amazon, eBay, Hotels.com, Buy.com, and Priceline, and 21 other entities.

The lawsuit, filed earlier this week, primarily targets anything that “allows users to complete a merchant transaction without the need to generate a voice call.”

As expected, the pro-Microsoft Richard Waters normalises this sick status quo, but the gory details (cited and quoted by Microsoft Florian) are hidden behind a paywall. To quote the publicly-visible portion:

More than two decades ago, soon after starting out in the mobile phone business, Nokia found itself on the receiving end of a massive patent infringement lawsuit from the company that had pioneered cellular communications: Motorola.

The Finnish group was in a vulnerable position. As a newcomer, it lacked enough patents of its own to counter-sue Motorola and fight it to a standstill.

Another Microsoft booster, Preston Gralla, makes erroneous statements to belittle Google (over patent issues) and only later corrects his IDG troll piece by adding an update (but not correcting the headline):

Update: The issue about Xoom WMA support isn’t directly related to Google and Android itself — it’s instead an issue with Motorola. As a commenter on this blog below notes, WMA and WMV support wasn’t baked directly into earlier Android versions. Instead, apparently Motorola added that support in its Droid, Droid 2, and Droid X. The company dropped it from Xoom.

For those who do not remember, Microsoft sued Motorola over Android/Linux, so no wonder Motorola evades this liability. That’s what happens when Microsoft decides to act like a patent troll and Motorola is actually one of the few companies (currently the only one) which stands up for Linux/Android against Microsoft’s patent demands. So well done, Motorola.

“That’s what happens when Microsoft decides to act like a patent troll…”The mobile space is becoming a sordid mess when it comes to patents and someone who pays close attention has noticed “Internet protocol (IP) phone with search and advertising capability”, which is yet another outrageous patent (joining the likes of “over the Internet” patents, this time being “on a phone” patent)

Michael Larabel, the revered editor of Phoronix whom I considered to be my online friend for years, is also recognising that software patents are becoming a huge problem for Linux. In his new and unusual post, “What Would Be Disastrous For Linux, Open-Source”, he writes:

Here’s a few that I thought of this morning. Feel free to share your Linux doomsday scenarios in the forums.

Patent trolls increasing their assertions against Linux and key open-source software. If the Linux market-share continues to rise, the frequency of patent attacks or free software projects being impaired by software patents will only continue to rise. Enough said.

[...]

Patent assertions against Mesa. Any direct legal attacks against the core Mesa (or Gallium3D) library would endager the Linux desktop. This would likely be the greatest threat to Linux user-space or in general short of claims against the Linux kernel. When it comes to graphics IP, this is a hot area and has already held up a number of features like S3TC support from being implemented in the mainline tree and other features that are protected by patents that will not expire for many years. This is preventing even core parts of the OpenGL 3.x specification from being implemented.

What makes this particularly dangerous is that there is no other open alternative for providing OpenGL support and hardware acceleration, short of starting over from scratch (or somehow salvaging ancient Utah-GLX code). Mesa is found installed on virtually every Linux desktop, whether it is used or not. If a project like GNOME or Compiz faced serious legal challenges, there’s still at least alternatives out there, but not for Mesa aside from installing proprietary AMD and NVIDIA drivers. Intel support though would then be killed off along with other obscure drivers. Even if GCC was attacked, there’s LLVM/Clang, Open64, and numerous other compilers out there, but when it comes to the user-space graphics, there’s really only Mesa.

[...]

The US government begins taxing open-source software. It’s actually not as crazy as it sounds and could actually happen.

Linux sites must wake up and start covering the software patents situation because it is the #1 barrier to landslide victory of Free software. Techrights was born from the need to fight back against Microsoft’s patent demands from Linux (Groklaw was created for similar reasons when SCO launched analogous attacks). Microsoft hires lobbyists to be dedicated to just beating the software patents drum. It knows why it’s doing that. █

Share this post: These icons link to social bookmarking sites where readers can share and discover new web pages.

Go there...
http://techrights.org/2011/04/02/patent-trolls-vs-rim/

Permalink Mail Send this to a friend

If you liked this post, consider subscribing to the RSS feed or join us now at the IRC channels.

Pages that cross-reference this one

You must be logged in to post a comment.

What Else is New

TechBytes Episode 36: “Come to Take Me Away”

Operating systems, form factors, and some Ubuntu derivatives
Links 3/4/2011: WebOS 3.0 SDK, Trisquel 4.5 and Many Other Distros Released

Links for the day
Red Hat's Obfuscated Patches Harm Small GNU/Linux Players and Help Microsoft/Novell

Suggestions to Red Hat, whose commitment to transparency has eroded somewhat and needs prodding for
Bill Gates and Nathan Myhrvold Find New Ways to Extort the Competitors, Using Patents

The world's biggest patent trolls proceed to extorting Blackberry users/devices; more news about software patents, mostly those which affect Android and Linux
The FFII Undresses the European Union

Transparency is achieved by activists from the Foundation for a Free Information Infrastructure (FFII) and a response is issued to Microsoft-funded claims that patents are good for startups
The 'Upgrade' Will Fix Everything™, Says Microsoft

The latest round of vapourware tactics from Microsoft helps show that Windows is having a crisis which is a matter of great urgency
Links 2/4/2011: Scientific Linux 6.0 Released, GNOME 3.0 Delays

Links for the day
Novell Leeching More, Creating Less

An overview of recent Novell news, of which there is a good deal about proprietary software, Red Hat leeching, LibreOffice/OpenOffice leeching, etc.
News About OpenSUSE 11.4, Possibly the Last OpenSUSE Release

A roundup of recent stories about OpenSUSE
Software Patents FUD a Sign That Microsoft is Losing, Linux is Winning

The Obama administration is said to considering a "fundamental rethink of software patents" just as Microsoft bets heavily on software patents
Market of Firefox (Free Software Poster Child) is Increasing While Windows Market is Decreasing

Firefox is growing up while Microsoft is growing old and its core business models erode
Legalising Corruption in Europe, the Microsoft Way

News from France and Switzerland, all showing that Microsoft is pretty much above the law
Microsoft-sponsored Distortion of News in the UK (Lerner Daemonises Free Software Along With Schankerman)

In order to derail government migration plans to Free/open source software (in the UK and elsewhere) Microsoft pays Lerner and a colleague from LSE, Schankerman, to echo Microsoft's old FUD
ES: Porqué la Comisión Europea de hoy Podría Hacer Frente a Una Demanda Legal Por Venderse a Microsoft

Las ofertas de ser vendedor-neutrales para los licitaciones que la Comisión Europea debe predicar no son incluso un principio honrado para la Comisión misma; Jan Wildeboer habla hacia contra este comportamiento inaceptable.
Links 1/4/2011: Linux 2.6.39 Previews, GNOME 3 Live Images

Links for the day
It Takes Microsoft Managers to be Malicious

Traul Allen (a patent troll who co-founded Microsoft) exposes Bill Gates as pathologically evil
Tribute to Schroder and Unanswered Questions

Tribute to Linux Today editor
Microsoft Declares Bankruptcy (Chapter 11)

April first post
Head of Microsoft Marketing Quits

Mich Mathews quits Microsoft after over two decades working with this monopolist
Software Freedom Perspective: 2006-2011

A look back at 5 years of Open Source, Linux, and Techrights
The FFII Reports Bad Faith at the European Patent Office
”In Europe Microsoft Have Been Putting Significant Resources in Backing The Setting Up Of the European Patent Office“

How Microsoft lobbies to change public policies such that they discriminate, intentionally, against software freedom
Why Today's European Commission Could Face Legal Action for Selling Out to Microsoft

Vendor-neutral tendering processes which the Commission ought to be preaching for is not even a tenet honoured by the Commission itself; Jan Wildeboer speaks out against this unacceptable behaviour
Restoration of Pace

Idle time is over as Internet service is up to speed and news starts rushing in
Links 30/3/2011: OLPC Training and “Linux Today” Re-rectified

Links for the day
Patents Roundup: Ill-conceived System Under Siege, Microsoft's Attacks on Linux and Google's Response

Opposition to software patents appears to be on the rise and Microsoft's lawsuits against Linux distributors (whom Microsoft just cannot compete with) contribute to this opposition; Google and Red Hat are encouraged to abolish software patents altogether, not adapt to them
Microsoft Helps Repressive Regimes, Whereas GNU/Linux Makes Those Regimes Powerless

Microsoft is gunning down dissidence (for oppressive tyrants only) by deliberately leaving people who use Microsoft software exposed to surveillance and other abuses
Why Microsoft's Guy Miguel de Icaza Pushes for C# at Apple, Which is Not Successful

Continued Mono lobby in Apple's platforms; The empires of ripoff show their continued exploitation of freely-shareable and free/open source-implemented ideas
When Microsoft Changes International Law to Make GNU/Linux Illegal

Microsoft's distortion of the law goes more global with the attempt to marginalise freedom in software using legal instruments, not technical merit
Links 29/3/2011: Beta of Red Hat Enterprise Linux 6.1, Bodhi Linux 1.0.0 is Out

Links for the day